Skip to Content

Why Coffee Quality Control Matters (And How It Happens)

If you’re like most people, your relationship with coffee begins at the café counter or your kitchen mug.

But long before that espresso shot hits your cup, there’s an entire world of careful checks, tasting, measuring, and sorting happening behind the scenes. It’s called Quality Control — and it’s the reason your coffee doesn’t taste like hot disappointment every morning.

So, what is it? Who does it? And why should you care?

Let’s break it down, just a good old-fashioned trip through the bean belt.

It All Starts at the Farm.

The quality story begins the moment the coffee cherry is picked.

Ripe vs Unripe:  Farmers are trained to handpick only the red, ripe cherries. One underripe cherry in a handful can mess with the taste — it’s that sensitive. And it shows up after milling and after roasting. The unripe cherries appear as pales.

Sorting:  After harvest, cherries are hand-sorted. Floaters (the light ones) are separated from sinkers (the good ones). Yes, this is literally done in water. Like bean Tinder. The sinkers (heavy ones) are the preferred ones and move on to a more specialised processing. The light ones are usually sun dried.

Processing Methods: Natural, washed, honey — these are not flavour names, but how the coffee is processed after picking. Each method impacts the final taste. Don’t fret, we’ll have a comprehensive piece on this. A bit later, for now, let’s continue!

Bottom line: If a farmer doesn’t pay attention here, no roaster or barista can “fix” it later.

The Middlemen With Microscopes (Not Literally)

After processing, the beans are dried, milled, and moved to licensed warehouses or approved stores where quality control gets more… serious.

Grading: Beans are sorted by size and density. Bigger isn’t always better, but uniformity matters.

Defect Checking: Broken beans? Black beans? Insect damage? They’re all spotted and scored. It’s like a beauty pageant for beans — with taste as the final test. We say coffee doesn’t keep quiet. Whatever the farmer or processor did to it, it will still shout. There are farm and processing / handling defects. Insect damage is a farm defect, while mouldy / blacks is mostly a processing defect.

Moisture Content: Beans are tested for moisture. Too much and they spoil. Too little and they age badly. Goldilocks vibes: it has to be just right (usually around 10–12%).

The Magic of Cupping

This is the fun part. And yes — slurping is encouraged.

Cupping is the official coffee tasting process. Trained tasters (some are called Q Graders) brew small bowls of coffee and score them on:

* Fragrance & Aroma

* Acidity (not the bad kind)

* Body (think mouthfeel)

* Flavour and Aftertaste

* Balance & Sweetness

Each coffee gets a score out of 100 according to the SCA. The closer to 90, the more “specialty” it becomes. Anything above 80 is considered good. Coffee can either be commercial, premium or specialty.

Each coffee origin, however, has their preferred scoring method and there’s no one-fit-all system. But ultimately, the goal is to understand how attractive (or not) that particular lot is.

If a coffee tastes off, they trace it back — maybe the drying was poor, maybe the fermentation went wrong. This helps producers improve over time.

The Roaster’s Role.

Once the green beans pass all the tests, they go to the roaster who takes green coffee and transforms it into the brown beans you know and love.

Test Roasts: Roasters will do small sample batches first, adjusting temperature curves to bring out the best in the beans.

Tasting Again: Yep, another cupping session. This helps decide how to roast for different flavour profiles — fruity, nutty, chocolaty, or wild and funky.

The Final Step — You

Believe it or not, you are part of the quality chain too.

If you:

* Store your beans in an airtight container

* Use clean water and the right grind size

* Brew with intention (or at least don’t boil the life out of the coffee)

…then you’re honouring the work of everyone before you.

 Why It All Matters

Because coffee is not just coffee.

It’s hundreds of hands. Weeks of drying. Dozens of decisions. All so that your cup can taste smooth, bright, and balanced — not bitter, stale, or flat.

Quality control isn’t about snobbery. It’s about respect for the farmer, for the roaster, and for the drinker.

So the next time you take a sip and say, “Damn, that’s good coffee”, — just know…

It didn’t get that way by accident.

From farm to cup — quality is a journey. And now, you're a part of it.

Writer: Gakuo Wanjohi

Peter Gakuoh July 18, 2025
Share this post
Archive
Master the art of coffee grinding.
Discover how the right grind size transforms your Over a Drink specialty coffee, from French Press to Espresso, for truly exceptional flavour.